Approximating Java Case Objects without Project Lombok

LombokOver the past few months Dick Wall of the Java Posse has been talking up Project Lombok and for good reason. As he points out, its great for reducing boilerplate code in basic Java data objects. However, the more important point that Dick makes is that it prevents stupid errors, particularly when adding new object fields later on in the development cycle. The only unfortunate issue is that Project Lombok requires a compiler hack that can be rather confusing to those not using a supported IDE or for those coding outside of an IDE. However, Apache Commons provides an elegant solution to this issue.

Project Lombok

Lets start with a quick overview of Project Lombok. At its most basic level it provides a set of annotations (i.e. @Data) that you add to your Java data objects. You simply create private fields in an annotated object and the annotation will cause a full set of constructors, getters/setters, equals/hashCode and toString to be generated in the class file at compile time while keeping a simple and minimal source file. Its an elegant solution but it comes with a fair amount of magic surrounding it.


The simple alternative to Project Lombok is to have the IDE generate the code for you. Eclipse, for instance, is very good at doing this with auto generation of constructors, getters/setters, hashCode/equals and toString. This works wonders when creating the object for the first time but, as Dick points out, its too easy to add a new field and forget about updating toString and hashCode/equals leading to confusing and subtle bugs down the road.

The other alternative, and the one I am promoting, strikes a balance between Project Lombok and IDE generation by auto generating the hashCode/equals and toString and leaving the getters/setters and constructors up to the developer as these are necessary for the new field to be of any use.

Apache Commons

Buried deep in the Apache Commons is the builder package containing utilities such as EqualsBuilder, HashCodeBuilder, and ReflectionToStringBuilder. I don’t remember when I first discovered these gems but once I did the lightbulb went off; if used them in an Abstract base class they would ensure proper implementations of equals/hashCode and toString without having to mess with every data object I create.

import org.apache.commons.lang.builder.EqualsBuilder;
import org.apache.commons.lang.builder.HashCodeBuilder;
import org.apache.commons.lang.builder.ReflectionToStringBuilder;
import org.apache.commons.lang.builder.ToStringStyle;

public abstract class AbstractBaseObj {

    public boolean equals( final Object obj ) {
        return EqualsBuilder.reflectionEquals( this, obj );

    public int hashCode() {
        return HashCodeBuilder.reflectionHashCode( this );

    public String toString() {
        return new ReflectionToStringBuilder( this).toString();


Of course this option is not with out its own drawbacks compared to Project Lombok. First off, as mentioned before, it does not deal with getters/setters or constructors. However, as I pointed out, I don’t believe this to be a huge imposition since creating a new field without creating getters/setters and/or a constructor using that field is fairly useless. Additionally, I like that this gives ease and flexibility over which constructors are created. This has been quite handy in the most recent project I’ve been working on.

Another draw back is that it requires an Abstract base class from which all objects must inherit. Annotations are certainly a more elegant solution since it doesn’t require a given object hierarchy. However there are often good reasons for a project specific base object for reasons beyond just equals/hashCode and toString. Additionally, the base class is fully owned by the project with just the few methods necessary being implemented. This is significantly better than having to inherit from a class provided by some 3rd party jar.

The important drawback, however,  is that the Apache Commons solution uses reflection instead of actually generating code to implement equals/hashCode and toString. Depending on how frequently these are used and how performant they need to be this might be a real consideration to use either Project Lombok or to write all the code directly. However, I have not found this to be the case in my project as it never seems to show up as a hot spot in any profiling I have done.

11 Lesser Known 3rd Party Libraries For Every Project

pennies_in_jar_small The Java 3rd party library ecosystem is a wild wild place. While everyone has heard of the big players such as Spring and Hibernate, too often the more humble, but equally important, libraries get left out in the cold.  It is for that reason that I give you the 11 lesser known 3rd party libraries that no project should be without.

Unit Testing

As always, the easiest place to start playing around with new libraries and languages is in unit tests.  I’m convinced they would be worth writing if only as an outlet for developers to try new and interesting tools, let along the code quality improvements.


While we can quibble over including databases in unit tests or if they are integration tests the fact of the matter is that at some point most people write a unit test that requires a database with some preexisting data.  Thats when DBUnit shines. It has the ability to use xml from a file or a string or any other type of input to clean and populate database tables with ease.  It even has some nice utilities for asserting data after a test has run.


On the other end of the spectrum from full blown database integration is mocking. When you need to disentangle an object from its myriad of dependancies and test it in isolation mock objects come to the rescue. There are a number of solutions out there but Mockito takes the cake. To see why I prefer it to EasyMock check out their comparison. They’ve even added some niceties for BDD style testing.

Hamcrest Matchers

Since Junit 4.4, a core set of hamcrest matchers has been included with the distribution and has gone a long way to simplifying assertions by through a pseduo english DSL. For even more power you can include the whole hamcrest matcher jar and start playing with features such as asserting the contents of collections.

Apache Commons


Most projects start with one properties file and before you know it there are two, then three, then ten and it gets out of control. You have static singletons that pull files off the class path and you’ve gone off the deep end. Thats why I say start Commons Configurations, even for that first file. Not only does it greatly simplify dealing with properties from the api point of view but it allows for pulling properties from xml, jdbc, property files, and much more. Its can even work as a simple api for dealing with xml in a jiffy.


These days with Spring JDBC, iBatis, Hibernate, ActiveObjects, and a host of other frameworks and libraries for dealing with JDBC its pretty easy to never have to directly touch the stuff.  However, if you find yourself in the hell which is closing a connection, session, and statement (with all the null checks and finals and exceptions and oh dear god) then Commons DbUtils is for you.  A simple close() method is provided which handles all the null checking and try catching and so on. So basic and yet so helpful.


This one might be a bit more obscure but if you have ever needed to simply read the contents of a file you have no doubt been stymied by which reader gets wrapped by which buffered writer and who flushes what. Commons IO provides a beautifully simple api for file reading as well as some nice utility methods, similar to DbUtils, for closing all those annoying objects with out all the hassle.


If there was one library on my list it would come down to this or Google Collections. Commons Lang is the place for every utility method you have ever thought of writing. Every time you have though of creating a null safe version of any of the String methods, StringUtils has your back. If you have though of doing the same for Booleans then BooleanUtils is for you. Same for Object and ObjectUtils. But it doesnt stop there, StringUtils has more methods than you can shake a stick at and then there is the Builder package. The Builder package contains a Hashcode, ToString, Equals and CompareTo builder. Better yet they contain methods to build these values dynamically based on reflection. I’ve taken to making a base class from which all my domain objects inherit  that simply overrides Hashcode, ToString and Equals with the reflection based builders. Never again do you need to create these annoying methods by hand or have Eclipse generate them only to forget to regenerate when you add another field.

New Kids On The Block


Logging, everyone needs it. Thats probably why there are at least four major Java logging frameworks.  However, they are not all created equal. Java util logging is known to have a number of shortcomings when compared to Log4J and Commons Logging is just a facade that allows you to switch between the two more easily. Out of this mess comes SLF4J. Created by the creator of Log4J it is simply a set of interfaces that anyone can implement. The default implementation, also made by the same guy, is called logback and takes all the best of Log4J and improves on it. Moreover there are converters that route Log4J, CommonsLogging, and Java util logging to SLF4J. Never again do you have to struggle with multiple libraries and configuration files for all of your 3rd party libraries in your project. Simply drop in the converters and everything nicely flows into SLF4J.

Google Collections

Like I said before, if there were one library on my list it would come down to Commons Lang and Google Collections. If you have every used Commons Collections and cursed at its lack of type safety then Google Collections is for you. If you have ever balked at having to write List<Map<String, List<Integer>>> only to realized you have to type it all over again on the left hand side of the value assignment then Google Collections static methods such as newHashMap() are for you. If you are looking for a poor mans cache then MapMaker is for you. Finally, if you want to play around with functional programing ideas in Java look no farther than Predicate and Function and take it as a challenge to remove all for loops from your application.


Database pooling, if you connectot to a database you need it. There are a few out there to choose from and the decision is always a bit of an argument but since Hibernate chose c3p0 as its default connection pool it has gotten significantly more attention than the other options and the prevailing winds seem to suggest that it is the way to go.

Joda Time

Not everyone has to deal with time in their programs but if you do, look no farther than Joda Time. From simple formatting to the complication of subtracting dates and everything in between, Joda Time is an easy to use api for all your date and time needs. No longer will you have deal with Calendars and wonder what exactly is a Gregorian one.


Get every new post delivered to your Inbox.